What are the hardest arguments for an atheist to refute in a Debate against a Theist ?

In a logical debate, the hardest arguments to refute are those that have nothing to do with logic:

ATHEIST: There is no evidence for the existence of God.

THEIST: Of course there isn’t. That is because God wants you to have faith. Faith does not require evidence. Faith is the opposite of evidence.

ATHEIST: That doesn’t make sense.

THEIST: Of course it doesn’t. God doesn’t want to make sense to you. God is beyond making sense. God is like love. Does love make sense?

ATHEIST: Sure, love is a feeling of extreme empathy that arises from our need to protect the species and…

THEIST: Exactly. It doesn’t make any sense! It is spiritual!

ATHEIST: That’s not what I said.

THEIST: But it is what you meant.

ATHEIST: No it isn’t.

THEIST: It would be if you stopped worrying about what makes sense and just let God into your heart.

ATHEIST: I can’t debate with you if you won’t let me make my own arguments!

THEIST: Thank you for acknowledging I won the debate. But it wasn’t really me. IT WAS GOD THAT WON THE DEBATE!!!