Environmental Issues: Grand Canyon 4

in #steemstem5 years ago

The Air: Life Itself

“... The Chrome and Steel she rides colliding with the very air she breathes. …”
Neil Young Unknown Legend

Look At The Grand Canyon!

Or not. Some days, there is so much haze in the air from a nearby coal fired power plant that you can barely see from rim to rim. Seriously.

Coal Haze 2.JPG
Photo courtesy of the author. Saddle Mountain is on the very northeast edge of the Park. The coal haze is apparent.

The Navajo Generating Station is less than 20 miles from the Grand Canyon and is considered one of the dirtiest power plants in the US. How can the Navajo Tribe do such a thing to the very place they consider the most sacred on earth? Isn’t that a contradiction in terms for the tribe that considers itself to be the stewarts of the Canyon?

Like everything else in and around Grand Canyon National Park, it’s complicated. The Navajo tribe has long been considered to be one of the poorest in the nation, particularly as measured by personal income.

Just after WWII the Navajo Reservation was found to hold a significant coal deposit. It was a way out of the crushing poverty that the tribe had lived in for 50 years. Mining and Power Generation were presented as a way to raise the income level for every tribal member. The tribe bought into it and allowed the project to proceed.

Coal Haze 1.JPG
Photo courtesy of the author. Looking toward the confluence, the haze makes it an ordinarily useless view.

In all actuality, the tribe has nothing to do with the management of the power plant or the mining operation. In what turns out to be a naive decision, the tribe trusted the developers. So today, the NAVAJO Generating Station provides a blight on the Canyon.

The tribe has done what they can. The supply rail line from the mine to the plant is all electric. No pollution from the trains. The tribe has currently decided that when the leases expire the plant and mine will be shuttered. But it’s years in the future.

Cars Too

There are certain atmospheric conditions that can deliver Phoenix grade air to the Grand Canyon. Phoenix works hard at air quality and the freeway system in and around the metro area mostly works, lowering overall pollution. But it’s still the 3rd or 4th largest metro area in the US and clouds of air pollution can be problematic and when the winds and temps are right it can flow right into the Grand Canyon. Las Vegas and it's slow moving traffic is even closer.

Car Haze.JPG
Photo courtesy of the author. North Rim view. See that yellowish band just above the South Rim? That's automotive pollution.

Even the popularity of the park can work against itself regarding air pollution. At times there are so many people entering the park through the South Entrance that there becomes a sort of micro climate that tends to trap the CO2 and CO1 at low levels which tends to funnel it right into the canyon.

All in all, the canyon does quite well with vehicle borne air pollution, so who cares if a little gets through? The Condors care.

California Condor

Pollution and habitat loss were part of the decline of the California Condor that led to an emergency plan to protect the very last of the species and prevent extinction.

The Condor is the largest bird in North America and one of the rarest. When the US government decided that they needed to step into the debate in 1987 by capturing all the remaining Condors to facilitate a captive breeding program. There were 27 living California Condors in 1987. By 1991 the program had succeeded to the point where Condors were reintroduced to the Grand Canyon. There are now 463 individuals in the wild. While they are still listed as ‘critically endangered’ because of low population, the numbers and the birds chances are better every year.

california-condor-581277_1920.jpg
Source

You can see the Condors mostly from the South Rim. They were incredibly shy and hard to see for the first 10 years of the introduction but for most of this century they have been fairly easy to see for yourself.

I’ve seen Condors multiple times at the Grand Canyon and haven’t a serviceable picture to show. I just can’t seem to get my camera up in front of my face when the Condors are in the area. They are so majestic and big that it seems I just can’t take the time or effort to show them.

Success Breeds Success

The last known Blackfooted Ferret was found between Williams and Flagstaff Arizona in 1931 when they were considered to be extinct.

Some time after that a small colony was discovered in the wild but by the time it was discovered and a plan made to trap the survivors there were only 18 left on earth. The number was considered too small to be viable but the effort was launched nonetheless.

It worked. BF Ferrets have been reintroduced at several sites throughout the western US. Two of those sites are in Arizona and near the canyon. Both sites in Arizona are on private land in cooperation with landowners and various state and federal agencies.

bfferret.jpg
Source

The original release for the BF Ferret was in an extremely wild area in Badlands National Park. The Ferret reintroduction plan has been a raging success. There are now thought to be over 1000 individuals living in the wild. That is a nice rise from 18 individuals all in captivity in 1981.

The Grand Canyon is at once fragile and solid as a rock. Threatened but still standing as a natural monument like no other. It’s up to us now. You and me. What do we want to leave for our children and generations to follow? A beautiful place that is just barely hanging on, or a place for the generations to come?

If you are moved to action by what you’ve read and need to do something you can support the Grand Canyon Trust and tell your congressman to support the Grand Canyon Centennial Protection Act.

I’m going to stick with the Colorado River (and it’s tributaries) as we look at the environmental concerns that dog the whole drainage basin in my next post. Thanks for following along!

You want to hear the Neil Young song referenced at the top? The Video "Unknown Legend" is right here. Part of it was filmed in Seligman, AZ which is on Route 66 right near the Grand Canyon. If you find yourself in Seligman be sure to stop for a burger at the Sno-Cap Drive Inn. You will not regret the visit.

All words in this post are mine. The photographs are either sourced properly or taken by me and used courtesy of the author.

You want some really cool stuff? Check these authors, they will not disappoint.

@broncofan99 Sports Teaching Fishing BBQ. Not necessarily in that order.

@morkrock Music Games Stinging Politics. Don't go here with thin skin.

@princessmewmew Food Antiques Food Life Food Cats. Anything of beauty could show up here.

@soyrosa Great Photographs and Insights for us All

@enchantedspirit Astrology and much more. Detailed analysis and more with grace and humor...

The STEEM Engine

Sort:  

Sno-Cap Drive Inn??? I've been there!! Cars with eyeballs, seriously! Nobody would ever forget that place! I lived outside of Phoenix for a couple of years and spent many hours running the trek from there to The Canyon and all the very cool places Arizona has to offer!

Your article was so well written, verbose enough to make it awesome and very well articulated. (I borrowed that from Quill) It was interesting and went over some things, like the Navajo history that I already knew and was pleased to read them in a little more detail.

Thank you! Thank you! So well done!

Upped and Steemed

!tip

We have a lunch meeting once a year at the Sno Cap. 12 to 20 Motorcycle riders show up for lunch and stories. That guy that owns the Sno-Cap is third generation. His grandfather built it out of 're purposed' lumber right after WWII. It's a crazy fun place.

It's easy for me to write about the Canyon. It's a place that I not only love, but that sings it's song to me. I really understand about some of the compromises that have gotten us here and now with the Canyon at risk.

Thanks for a stunning comment. I really appreciate it.

Ferrets are pretty awesome. I have an old friend that keeps them as pets and the pictures she posts are always really cute. It's too bad the tribe couldn't look into some of the advancements that are being made in Small Modular Nuclear Reactors. The newer ones are immune to meltdowns and EMP's. They also require a relatively small footprint compared to traditional power plants.

I actually had a little interaction with the Black Footed Ferret project. I knew a couple that were both PHD candidates at WSU and they actually had a pair at their house for remote breeding purposes. I think the pair they had were 3rd generation. And they were pretty cool creatures...

I don't know what the tribe is going to do beyond close that coal plant when the contracts run out. They may well look into those small reactors. The concept would work really well on that res.

I heard a report just yesterday that the company has been accepted for a test run at Idaho National Laboratory. (Twin Falls, ID) Their purpose there will be as 'fill in' for a wind and solar project. Their quick spool up and down time is the key to the test to provide continuous power after dark and when the wind isn't blowing. Should be interesting.

That is really cool! I like mongooses too. If I lived in an area where there are poisonous snakes, I would definitely have a pet mongoose! Is that Nuscale that is building the fill-in power station?

It is Nuscale. I heard it yesterday on NPR and remembered your interest in it.

Should be really interesting. The Nuscale guy said "We have a battery with a two year charge rate in this project. Our reactors will be cheaper than the same kwh in batteries."

Wow, this is both heartbreaking and heartwrming @bigtom13. We just watched an amazing documentary about the Grand Canyon this weekend and to hear about this pollution along with the attempts to build a tram down to the floor of the canyon...geesh. So glad to hear about the beautiful condor and sweet ferret. It takes just a few caring individuals to speak out and affect change in a big way. Your posts are a great education to all of us, thank you :)

There are some things that can be changed and some that can't at the Canyon. Water usage of the river is fixed, cant be fiddled with. The Navajo have a contract until 2030 with the power provider. We could be done with single use plastic bottles. There are things we CAN do.

The success with the BF Ferret and the Condor are just amazing. Both were listed as extinct. Not a single one left in the wild. Now here they are. The Condors soaring on the thermals out of the canyon are just an exciting sight to behold. They are BIG.

I find these posts so interesting but so shocking at the same time, I do feel for the Navajo, being stuck in this prediciment, but at leat they are doign what they can and plan to shut it down when the contract ends a pity that is far in the future

We really need to all step up and do what we can to protect our planet

I can't even blame the power company. They felt they needed a 50 year contract to recoup all the expenses that they put in. Power prices have risen more than they expected at the start of the project so they have done well, and actually try to contain emissions from the plant.

It's a microcosm of the world in general. Decisions made 50 years ago or more aren't good now, but....

I hope we aren't too late coming to the aid of the planet. I personally don't think we are, but I also think we need to get after it soon or we will be too late. A sad future indeed.

Thats a good point about the plant and at least they are also trying to do things to reduce emissions
And yes indeed i do understand it is just one example of the same type of thing happening all over the world, and I to hope we are not to late but changes need to be made now we really cant put blinkers on and ignore it which so many are seeming to do these days which is scary,
I think its clearly beyond debate that the planet has been damaged by us and its time to make amends before it is too late

It's good to know about these initiatives to preserve important wildlife, and that they seem to be working. I would never blame the Navajo for going ahead with a coal mine at a time when coal was widely used throughout the western world. Now we're all learning about the benefits of the type of non-destructive lifestyle that the Navajo and other tribes lived for centuries, before they were told that the "civilised" type of lifestyle was the best. It's all about balance.
Thanks for presenting such a clear and readable view of this fascinating subject. I hope I'll be able to visit the Grand Canyon some day.

I actually think we are going to end up using 'tribal wisdom' in a lot of our choices going forward. They have been taking their environment into consideration for a long time.

I hope that you can visit the Canyon some day, too. I have a feeling you would like some of the trails such as Bright Angel. Amazing views and geology at your fingertips. Every 100m you go down is 50,000 years in the past :)

Bright Angel sounds wonderful. I've looked it up on Wikipedia, and it seems that the biggest danger from animals is squirrel bites. We have vicious squirrels in Glasgow too, so I should feel quite at home :)

A lot of vertical in the Bright Angel trail, but it's a really well traveled route and very much do able. The perspective from the bottom of the canyon is much different from the top. Not to mention that some of the oldest rocks known to exist live there in the bottom.

Squirrels are not particularly aggressive at the Canyon, I'd think the biggest animal threat on the Bright Angel would be burro poop. A string of burros goes from rim to river and back every day. Lots of tourists take that option.

Aw - I love donkeys! But I'd probably go on foot :)

So sad that the Navajo now find themselves in this position because of poverty! The Condor is a magnificent bird not so, glad to hear that their numbers are increasing! Very enlightening series you're writing @bigtom13.

Posted using Partiko Android

Right after the war they jumped at the chance to build a large scale power plant. It added (and still adds) millions to their tribal functions. It really seemed the right thing, and it was a decision made based on the facts at the time.

The Navajo particularly aren't looking to become rich. Tribal custom doesn't define rich as 'owning much' but as knowing much. They are he only major tribe in the US that doesn't have a gambling interest. Which is amazing....

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

You got a 8.74% upvote from @ocdb courtesy of @bigtom13! :)

@ocdb is a non-profit bidbot for whitelisted Steemians, current max bid is 20 SBD and the equivalent amount in STEEM.
Check our website https://thegoodwhales.io/ for the whitelist, queue and delegation info. Join our Discord channel for more information.

If you like what @ocd does, consider voting for ocd-witness through SteemConnect or on the Steemit Witnesses page. :)

🎁 Hi @bigtom13! You have received 0.1 SBD tip from @dswigle!

@dswigle wrote lately about: Hail Tree Tuesday! Feel free to follow @dswigle if you like it :)

Sending tips with @tipU - how to guide :)

Congratulations! This post has been chosen as one of the daily Whistle Stops for The STEEM Engine!

You can see your post's place along the track here: The Daily Whistle Stops, Issue 476

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.26
TRX 0.11
JST 0.032
BTC 64555.14
ETH 3086.03
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.85