Art Plagiarism: A Curable Cancer in The Steem Platform

in #utopian-io5 years ago (edited)

Jaguar-Sepia-Halbwchsig-Profile-Free-Image-Cat-He-1805.jpg
CC0

"My Art"

Since the beginnings of the Steem platform a cancer established itself in it: the cancer of art plagiarism. Art plagiarism is a disease of this platform and Jaguar Force is a part of the cure.

QsEsnCD4.jpg
Source

How Did We Get Here?

This tumor progressively grew, metastasized, by a mechanism of action that involved mainly 4 factors:

  1. The initial art plagiarists were rewarded handsomely, these rewards reinforced the practice, fed the tumor and thus promoted it's growth. These initial plagiarists in view of the rewards then created large rings of accounts to exploit this vulnerability.

  2. Many users that were not initially art plagiarists saw this phenomenon unfold and in view of the profitability of the scheme mimicked it, replicating the behaviour and expanding the problem.

  3. Real artists that refused to engage in art plagiarism fell into a disadvantage by not being able to compete with those plagiarizing, and thus most of those real artists progressively left the platform.

  4. Antiabuse initiatives maintained their scopes regarding art plagiarism static after a certain point in time, which resulted in art plagiarists perfecting and sophisticating their art plagiarism techniques, transitioning from mostly art theft initially (directly stealing images of somebody else's art) to mostly art paraphrasing (reproducing somebody else's artwork with slight modifications, change of medium, etc.). This inability and/or unwillingness to dynamically adapt the scope allowed art plagiarism to remain unabated and thrive in the platform.

cff6fJyE.jpg
Source

The Good Fight

In all fairness there were, at the beginning of the platform, great cleaners like @pfunk and others that addressed and fought skillfully against art plagiarism in all its forms, including art paraphrasing. Those great cleaners were temporarily able to contain art plagiarism and at one point went so far as to halt account creation from the whole country of Ukraine and parts of Russia in a measure intended to neutralize and contain the largest art plagiarism ring Steem has seen, the Yanik art plagiarism ring, which still remains active to this day.

Those cleaners that at one point were able to contain the cancer of art plagiarism then because less active in antiabuse initiatives or left the platform, which led to the rampant state of art plagiarism in Steem today.

pjimage(3).jpg
Source

Be The Change You Want To See In The Platform

A few months ago Jaguar Force decided that enough was enough. That the issue needed to be put back on the table, that art plagiarism in all its forms needed to be fought, engaged, reported and exposed. That it was time to fight the good fight against art plagiarism in order to turn Steem into a platform that rewards and welcomes real artists and not art fraudsters.

"First They Ignore You, Then They Laugh at You, Then They Fight You, Then You Win."

In these months since we started engaging art plagiarism we faced a multitude of problems, complications and obstacles, most of which coming naturally from art plagiarists themselves, their supporters (i.e. major stakeholders and witnesses that could not admit they were duped by these fraudsters) and those in the platform that benefit from it (i.e. Art dapps that benefit from the apparent value that art plagiarism provides the content they curate and reward) but some of it coming from unexpected sources as for example otherwise competent cleaners that allegedly act in the name of logic and reason.

Jaguar Force overcame every single one of those obstacles, complications and problems. To mention just a few of the victories in this not yet finished campaign we can mention the point in which @ntopaz instituted a new set of rules that reflected exactly the rules Jaguar Force was advocating for.

Another significant victory was the institution by @steemflagrewards of the art paraphrasing category, which allowed for an initial and provisory flagging capability that was deployed during the engagement of some of the cases detected.

A more recent and crucial victory in this campaign is merely days old, when @steemcleaners adapted their scope to include art paraphrasing, considering it a type of art plagiarism.

During this process Jaguar Force undoubtedly established itself at and as the vanguard of art plagiarism antiabuse engagement. We served as an arrowhead, as the small element that makes contact and pierces through first, then to be followed by the long shaft of the metaphorical arrow.

fd0qEJ6U.jpg
Source

The Way Forward

Make no mistake, this campaign has just started, the night is young and we are aware that many more obstacles will emerge in the way of its completion. We are ready, prepared and determined to overcome each and every single last one of them. We will cross those bridges when we get to them, even those that don't exist yet, for where a bridge is needed that is not there, we will build it.

We will continue on this full spectrum campaign of detection, engagement and neutralization of art plagiarism by any means we deem appropriate until we consider that the situation has been contained.

This is Jaguar Force,
Reporting directly from the Jungle.
Onwards!

Sort:  

Howdy @jaguar.force,

You know this has been a highly contentious issue on our server but I agree with you in principle. I want to make it clear that I believe the methodology past the detection phase needs work (primarily in the area of PR) but I believe you are working to that end.

It would be helpful if you can actually rally artists behind you and we can see their concurrence in the comments. For that reason, I highly recommend you focus on building support. Bring the fight against art-paraphrasing into the mainstream consciousness.

There are a few shortfalls to this campaign I can readily identify. First of all, you regular abuse fighter is not equipped with the techniques you employ as they are proprietary. I understand the concern that abusers being made aware may take additional steps to conceal. What would be really cool is a JaguarForce API or a software that users can invoke on a post to reveal the sort of things you are able to find via your deep analysis.

Perhaps, a piece of software will never be as good as a keen pair of eyes but, at least, it may be possible to share the more basic components via an API. Alternatively, you could look into an incentive system for users reporting. Empowering users to participate in any way could serve as a massive catalyst for action. Getting the people behind you is crucial, especially the artists. When you critics see genuine support from the community, this may prompt them to reconsider their position. They may even join you.

As for the post, I want to share with you a screensnip of Hemingwayapp

Please, make sure you are using this so your post will be easier to read. It make the job of the moderator much easier not to mention other readers.

Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.


Need help? Chat with us on Discord.

[utopian-moderator]

Thank you for your review, @anthonyadavisii! Keep up the good work!

Hi @jaguar.force!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your post is eligible for our upvote, thanks to our collaboration with @utopian-io!
Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server

You already said more than you need!
drawing looking at the photo is allowed!
Why did not God give you a mind) is strange, how are you so cheated? lol

plagiarism Russia and Ukraine ??? What racism?
Wow, yes on Steemit also racism thrives thanks to such a foolish, mentally ill!
The community is getting better and better every day! Well done!
Daio seems to have banned the use of its art in your posts!
You did not listen to her.
You're plagiarism, thief and psychopath !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  1. Drawing looking at a picture (copying it) is allowed indeed, provided you link to and show the picture, and provided that the picture is free to use for commercial purposes with modifications (derivative works), otherwise you need permission by the author.

  2. Please read the definition of racism, it doesnt mean what you think it means.

  3. Daio cannot "bann" the use of her "artwork" in our posts, because since her "artwork" is in breach of the rights of the original authors, she doesnt have any rights over the derivative works. Additionally, even if she had those rights, it would fall within fair use, since we make abuse reports, not art blogs.

  4. Thank you for including that excellent meme.

Have a great day and thank you for your feedback.

Hey, @jaguar.force!

Thanks for contributing on Utopian.
We’re already looking forward to your next contribution!

Get higher incentives and support Utopian.io!
Simply set @utopian.pay as a 5% (or higher) payout beneficiary on your contribution post (via SteemPlus or Steeditor).

Want to chat? Join us on Discord https://discord.gg/h52nFrV.

Vote for Utopian Witness!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.32
TRX 0.11
JST 0.034
BTC 66761.99
ETH 3256.83
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.27