You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Ready-Made Steem SMT DEX: Bitshares?

in #bitshares5 years ago

I'm mixed about this. I know a lot of 3rd party devs have been pinning their hopes on SMTs for their apps. Okay, as some kind of share-holding-security token I can see some use case there. But then, BUILDTEAM has been running their token (with simulated stacking) on the BitShares chain for about a year now. Their system work - and you can see staked holdings by looking at a spreadsheet (cue: that Forbes article on blockchain being no smarter than a spreadsheet heh). <- This ramble basically means that if you want a security token then, where there's a will, there's a way. You don't need an SMT but it's certainly nice to have it baked into the blockchain.
My thoughts on SMTs as a utility token are mixed; I still think that there are only a few communities/dapps that have large enough communities with underlying value exchanges that warrant a special SMT. As a matter of economic design there's too many people pinning their hopes on it.
Onto the DEX. I guess you could create some cross-chain-swap-thing to BitShares to make a DEX work.
Though I thought the idea of SMTs was to do away with an order-book driven DEX in favour of an algorithmic DEX (ala Bancor). If that's the case then I think the features for this need to be baked into a very early release of SMTs at the blockchain level even if realising them into the UI takes some time. The early implementations don't even need to do SMT-SMT exchanges, they could simply do SMT-STEEM and STEEM-SMT and then let the UIs figure it out.
I'm still a bit skeptical about SMTs. Not super skeptical, but yeah. I think SteemInc needs to deliver on them to show that they are a trustworthy company for sure.
They could also do well to help promote third-party efforts at improving the general infrastructure. Steem appears to me to be a bohemoth of a thing that really could be made more reliable and more nimble if effort was put in that direction.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.30
TRX 0.12
JST 0.032
BTC 64215.81
ETH 3150.89
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.86