Oooh, I love it! And somehow I suspect "Carnation Caramel Cream Chess Pie" came straight from real life. I love the periwinkle blue vase (an antique, no less!) and the audacity of mixing pink and red. I totally believe he pulled it off. And I love it that you call this one of his superpowers. Now I'm dying for more David who bakes cakes!) and Evelyn (who is going to allowe herself a slice). Will she stop at just one? How else will David tempt her? That pink boutonnière - anything could happen!
Nope. Made it up. Just tried to make it sound as rich as I possibly could, then saw it had some handy alliteration with a consonant I myself am struggling to sing, so that part came from real life. But not the pie! I would hate that pie. I'm a bittersweet chocolate gal.