Headline: How Civil Must America Be?

From The New York Slimes

by JACQUI SHINE

GRINNELL, Iowa — All paths seem to cross at Saints Rest, a downtown coffee shop that opened in 1999. In the early morning, retirees amble over for kaffeeklatsch; later, professors from the college here meet students, who hunker down with laptops. Teenagers come by after school.

The adroit NYT reporter obviously correctly surmised that the best place to get the "real" view of a town is to go to the coffee shop next to the college and interview other lesbians. I apologize now, this article is absurdly long and you cannot unsee Jacqui Shine.

JACQUI SHINE

The shop’s name stems from a term of derision for the teetotaling, lecture-friendly Congregationalists who settled the town in the 1850s. Those days are long over. Grinnellians now tend to keep any impulse to hector one of their neighbors under wraps. ( I had to look up "hector", clearly Ms. Shine likes the thesaurus.)

What's funny is that she goes on to document efforts of local lesbians to hector the heck out a prominent town benefactor.

Pete Brownell, a well-known and well-liked local philanthropist, sometimes stops by Saints Rest for coffee on his way to work. He and his wife, Helen Redmond, have supported many projects in town, including a public library renovation and a residency program run by a local artists’ collective.

He is also the third-generation C.E.O. of Brownells, a major firearms company whose headquarters are here, which calls itself the country’s “leading supplier of firearm accessories, gun parts, and gunsmithing tools.” Brownells sells and manufactures guns and ammunition. For much of the last year, Mr. Brownell also served as chairman of the board of the National Rifle Association.

Sounds like a great guy, they are lucky to have such a guy in their town.

For some time, none of this attracted much notice. People certainly knew that their good, generous neighbor subsidizes their quality of life with money earned in the gun industry in a state where gun deaths run nearly neck and neck with drug overdose deaths, according to the Centers for Disease Control. But at Saints Rest and elsewhere, most people broach neither subject. There’s other stuff to chat about, like how things are going.

Whoop, there it is! "gun deaths" That's a term designed to mislead, they add up all suicides, homicides (both legal and not) and accidents and call them "gun deaths". Iowa is a rural place and rural people have higher suicide rates cross culturally and internationally and regardless of gun laws, social isolation is a casual factor in suicide, guns are not a cause of suicide they are a means. It's misleading to talk about gun deaths, let's talk about gun homicides, in terms of gun homicides, Iowa is one of the safest states in the country. Iowa, with almost no gun restrictions, is much safer than Hawaii with its absurd racist gun restrictions, high property values and the advantage of being a remote island group.

Grinnell is both progressive bastion and gun town, a place urbane and rural. It is home to an influential liberal arts college with an endowment of more than $1 billion, and also a Monsanto plant. Usually, these juxtapositions are a point of pride, if they are noteworthy at all.

Ms. Shine apparently thought that was noteworthy.

But since the mass shooting in Las Vegas last October, Mr. Brownell has become a divisive figure in town, to nearly everyone’s reluctance. The culture wars here — and all of the culture wars converge right here — may be about guns, or about religion, or they might be about money. But they may really be about manners.

Whatever it is obviously Ms. Shine has her finger on the pulse of this town, or something.

Here Are Your Neighbors

The first thing most everyone says is that the Brownells are good, generous people. Their children all go to school together. Mr. Brownell and Ms. Redmond care very much about making Grinnell a good place to live for everyone.

The second thing people say is that they want to protect the family’s privacy. Mr. Brownell’s family did not choose his occupation, people point out. Besides, Ms. Redmond, who is president of the board of the Grinnell-Newburg Community School District, votes Democratic and supported Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign. She has donated to the progressive state-level political action committee her neighbors created last year. Everyone is clear that Pete Brownell’s politics are his own.

Wow, that's what they call "virtue signaling", look at how virtuous she is!

The third thing is that they don’t have a problem with guns. “We all agree people have the right to own guns, and that using them for hunting is great and that’s fine,” said Tim Dobe, an associate professor of religion at Grinnell College. “No one challenges that.”

“I am in favor of the Second Amendment,” said The Rev. Wendy Abrahamson, rector of St. Paul’s Episcopal Church, right across the street from the college library. Her father was a hunter; she has also lost a loved one to gun violence.

"Gun violence" another newspeak term, in fact it is a synonym for "gun deaths" also a total of suicides homicides and accidents, as if they are all the same, the idea is that "gun deaths" and "gun violence" can only be addressed with gun restrictions. In reality suicide homicide and accidents are all different problems with different solutions and more gun laws are not effective solutions to any of them. Warning, you cannot unsee The Rev. Wendy Abrahamson.

The Rev. Wendy Abrahamson

And while Ms. Abrahamson quietly resigned from the board of a community arts center when she realized that the group has accepted money from the Brownells, she did not say so at the time.

Probably because it would sound stupid to resign because a gun seller supports the community arts center.

But over the last few years, the gun company in the middle of everything here became harder to ignore. In December 2012, The Los Angeles Times reported that Brownells sold several years’ worth of high-capacity ammunition magazines in the 72 hours after the mass shooting at the Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn. (There have been more than 100 F.B.I.-designated active shooter incidents since.)

What the heck do those two factoids have to do with each other? In fact they are completely unrelated. Here is a fun fact, according to the FBI more than three percent of those shootings were stopped by armed citizens, which does not sound like much unless you consider that less than 1% of people carry on a regular basis. That suggests we need more people carrying legally in more places, not fewer.

Then, in 2016, Brownells opened a massive new warehouse, office and retail complex on the outskirts of town. It looms over Interstate 80. In May 2017, Mr. Brownell became the president of the N.R.A.’s board. “Each of these things were pushing people toward discomfort,” Mr. Dobe said. “Las Vegas broke it open.”

Remember Mr. Dobe, his opinion is very valuable, he is an associate professor of religion at a bullshit college in Iowa. He is an expert on Bollywood. He also lists on his CV: Fall 2017-pres. Core Organizer, “26 Days of Action,” Gun reform activism

This disquiet eventually bubbled up online. “It was clear that people had been holding back their feelings,” said Eliza Willis, a professor of political science at Grinnell. A local Facebook group gave them the space to express their feelings. “All these people came out of the community making comments and expressing unhappiness about the facility and about his election to the presidency of the N.R.A.,” Ms. Willis said.

Eliza Willis contact info

Others expressed their disagreement and their concern for the Brownell family’s privacy.

“It got quite active and a little heated,” Ms. Abrahamson said. “It’s not like there’s a unified feeling about this.”

The fracas also underscored the fact that no one seemed to have talked to Mr. Brownell about any of it directly. A day or two after the Las Vegas shooting, Ms. Abrahamson said, she phoned his office to invite him to meet with her and another pastor, Cameron Barr, to discuss ways they might “work together to increase gun safety.” She said that her overture, which she repeated in a Facebook message, received no response.

Wow, he didn't respond to Facebook or phone call from some random gun haters?

A week later, other members of the Grinnellians for Change Facebook group sent a letter asking for Mr. Brownell’s attention. It was signed by 170 people and published in the Grinnell Herald-Register. The group wrote: “Nowhere are mutuality and reciprocity more important than in a small town such as ours.”

Sadly "Grinnellians for Change Facebook group" is a private group, perhaps someone wants to join? It does have over 500 members. Wow, they really ramped things up, going from a facebook post to a strongly worded letter!

What's next? Please don't make a feeble sign and take a picture of yourself with it, anything but that!

source

Mr. Dobe characterized their message this way: “Now that you’re the president of the N.R.A., we think you kind of owe us a conversation.”

No social justice warrior, he does not owe you shit, you own him a thank you for supporting the town. Join the NRA and then maybe he will want to talk.

Again, Mr. Brownell did not answer. “Pete Brownell did not respond as a neighbor,” said Kesho Scott,an associate professor of sociology and American studies at Grinnell. Ms. Scott’s and Mr. Brownell’s daughters are friends and sleep over at each other’s houses. The parents see each other at the bank. “All of a sudden he wasn’t responding to his neighbors,” Ms. Scott said.

Ms. Scott (note there are no misses in this story) unlearning a white boy

She teaches "global feminism". Her qualifications include "two decades of developing unlearning racism work". Obviously he should be seeking her input about his gun politics!

Friends of the Brownells, including the Grinnell city manager, Russ Behrens, say that neighborliness is a two-way street. Members of his family had seen the Facebook group’s angry, frustrated posts and comments, a couple of which suggested confronting Mr. Brownell with a vigil at his home.

“There were people that could have sat in a room and had a conversation,” Mr. Behrens said. He and other friends have talked privately in the past with Mr. Brownell about his views on gun safety. He felt things got out of hand online. “By that time Pete almost had to go to his corner because they had already kind of set the message in and made their attacks. Nothing good was going to happen from that point on.”

“It really prevented any type of conversation,” Mr. Behrens said.

Wow, their anti gun facebook page didn't achieve it's goals, shocking.

The tenor of the conversation might have made people who aren’t opposed to accepting money from Mr. Brownell “a little more afraid to talk,” according to Sam Rebelsky, a computer science professor and a friend of the family.

What they still have not stated is why anyone would be opposed to accepting his money, is it "dirty" money because he sells legal guns? The unsaid but very clear implication is that it is somehow immoral to sell legal guns to law abiding people for legal uses.

Mr. Brownell did meet with George Drake, a former president of the college who has been working with Ms. Abrahamson and others, on the condition that Mr. Drake keep the conversation confidential.

So after all that he did meet with their group, what a good neighbor, I would have told them to fuck off bought their college and shut it down and reopened it as a Christian's Constitution College.

Mr. Brownell’s neighbors say they want to build on whatever common ground they share with him on gun politics. First, they have to know what that might be. (He also declined to speak with me.)

These are not his neighbors, unless he lives on the college campus. These professors are not even from the town, they are all transplants.

His public remarks have been unsurprising in the national conversation, but also strike some as unneighborly. He echoes the N.R.A.’s talking points on the Second Amendment, repeating that people he characterizes as “anti-American” are trying to take away guns, which are our national heritage.

Indeed anyone who wants to take away people's guns or gun rights is unamerican and that is what is un-neighborly. How can anyone opposed to a fundamental American right be pro- American?

He has a familiar mix of gun politic signifiers about ecological preservation, wildlife restoration, respect for military veterans, police and emergency medical workers. He has also said that he wants the N.R.A. to be an inclusive organization that supports L.G.B.T.Q. gun owners and other marginalized groups.

That's funny, note how above she was virtue signaling about her lesbian anti gun friends but now poo-poos when someone she is biased against virtue signals. I would like to know more about how he would like to include "Q". First I would like to know what the fuck a "Q" is and then why and how they should be included.

Mr. Brownell’s tone never fully matched the most aggressive rhetoric stemming from the N.R.A., like that of Dana Loesch, of its spokeswomen. Ms. Abrahamson and others said that they had hoped Mr. Brownell was going to use his role to modulate the N.R.A.’s tone over what was supposed to be a two-year term. Nothing he has said in public suggests that he did.

That's sad, I bet she was praying her hardest.

His neighbors may want to believe that his so-called real views, the ones he would share in private, are different from what he has said publicly. They also suspect it may not really matter. Like it or not — and many do like it — gun money does a lot for Grinnell.

Bizarre that she keeps calling the local anti gun/ pride coalition his "neighbors" in a town of 9000 people.

The Finances of a Small Town

In 2016, Mr. Behrens told USA Today that Grinnell, like many other cities, is increasingly reliant on “philanthropic support for parks, aquatic centers and libraries.” The Brownells have supported the construction of a new skate park and a community garden, through donations to a redevelopment nonprofit.

And what have those college professors and lesbian preachers built?

They have also supported a robotics team at Grinnell-Newburg High School. They have contributed to the Grinnell Area Arts Council and the Poweshiek County Community Fund.

Brownells Inc., the gun company, has become an integral part of the economic health of the city. Alongside the college, Grinnell Mutual Insurance Company and the Grinnell Regional Medical Center, it is among Poweshiek County’s largest employers.

Founded in nearby Montezuma in 1939, where its headquarters were until 2016, Brownells was a relatively small and specialized business for its first 60 years.

Since Mr. Brownell joined the company as an executive vice president in 1997, Brownells has acquired three other firearms companies, become a military defense contractor, secured a patent for its online ordering system, opened a retail store and undergone two expansions, the first of which the company almost immediately outgrew upon its completion in 2011.

Mr. Brownell was planning to relocate the company to a larger city, like Des Moines or Kansas City, when Mr. Behrens asked him to consider somewhere closer to home. Poweshiek County, like many rural areas across the country, has experienced population plateauing or decline.

Reversing the trend, Mr. Behrens said, was the city’s primary consideration in courting the relocation. The Brownells expansion was expected to create at least 162 new jobs in Grinnell and stimulate the city’s housing market.

There was almost no public opposition to the Brownells project. Records say that no one appeared for the scheduled public comment session held immediately before the City Council signed an initial development agreement in November 2012.

With the exception of one letter to the editor of the Grinnell Herald-Register, Mr. Behrens said, “There was no pushback from the community at all,” in part because there was great value in keeping a three-generation family business — “hopefully soon to be fourth,” he added — in Poweshiek County. “It’s not like we went out and recruited some random gun manufacturer,” Mr. Behrens said. “This was about the expansion of an existing industry. We today have no reservations about doing it, and we would do it again.”

The facility’s grand opening, complete with a ribbon cutting attended by the governor of Iowa and Lou Ferrigno, took place in June 2016, the day before the Pulse nightclub shooting. The Pulse shooter had armed himself with a semiautomatic rifle and a Glock pistol. Brownells had given away prizes, including similar firearms, about 12 hours earlier.

Hey look, two more random unrelated factoids! Unless one of the prizes was used in the massacre by that Islamic Jihadist then the two incidents are totally unrelated. I guess too much history was painting Brownells as the town's savior.

This, says Kirsten Klepfer, the pastor of Grinnell’s First Presbyterian Church, “woke me up.” A week after the shooting, she preached an uncomfortable sermon at the Sunday morning service. “If we think there’s no connection between Orlando and Brownells, we’re probably not thinking hard enough,” she said.

Sorry to have to do this to you but I think its important to illustrate this story:

Ms. Klepfer

She noted that about two-thirds of annual firearms deaths are suicides. This, too, has a local connection; mental health resources in the city and state are dismal. Poweshiek County’s mental health center closed in 2013. Iowa ranked 47th in practicing psychiatrists per capita in 2016, and last among all states in per capita psychiatric bed availability.

Good point, most "firearms deaths" "gun deaths" and "gun violence" is intentional suicide! Therefor if any of these people actually gave a shit about Iowans or truly wanted to reduce "gun deaths" they would focus on suicide prevention efforts. But they want to pass gun restrictions, not save lives.

Ms. Klepfer told her congregation that, the day before the store opened, she had approached Brownells seeking financial support for a new behavioral health program that was having a cash flow crisis. She subsequently withdrew the request.

“I’m ashamed,” she told her congregants. It had become clear to her that “we like them when they pump our community full of money, we turn our eyes when they pump our communities full of guns.” She has since told another mental health organization she works with that she believes they should not take donations from Brownells.

Oh yeah, guns are a huge problem there, there was a total of ZERO murders there. Funny how they won't come out and say what the rational for not taking their money is.

Ms. Klepfer, the church’s leader for over a decade, may be the person with the strongest principled objection to what she sees as the community’s complicity in the firearms industry. She may also be the person who struggles least with the moral complexity and social risk of raising such objections. “There’s a reason we’re not a big church,” she said, “and it’s mostly me.”

Wow, she seems unusually self aware! But why wouldn't you be "complicit" with a legal and moral business?

The Pulse shooting also moved Janet Carl,the recently retired director of the college’s writing center, to action. Ms. Carl, who represented Grinnell in the Iowa Assembly for six years in the 1980s, said that the shooting prompted her to submit a letter to the Grinnell Herald-Register, the first she had ever written. After it ran, she was contacted by three other people who wanted to become more active on gun safety, colleagues who had had no idea that they shared her concerns.

Wow, her letter to the paper generated 3 replies!! This is important national news, excellent journalism. Here is Ms. Carl (is there a single Mrs. in this town?)

Ms Carl

This was the origin of an ad hoc organizing group, which grew after the 2017 Las Vegas shooting. The group planned several weeks of protests and educational events to coincide with the five-year anniversary of the Sandy Hook shooting, including a silent walk to the Brownells facility.

Why? What are they protesting? What is that supposed to do?

They invited David Wheeler, whose 6-year-old son was killed at Sandy Hook, to attend a screening of the documentary “Newtown.” In advance of his visit, Mr. Wheeler wrote to Mr. Brownell asking for a meeting. He received no response.

Why would he?

Every Town Is Two Towns

The “Newtown” screening took place on the college campus but was not a school-sponsored event, and the college has largely stayed out of local politics. Every faculty or staff member I spoke to was careful to say their efforts do not represent their employer. And the students, whatever their reputation for rabble-rousing, have not participated much in this off-campus effort.

They largely consider the school, rather than the town, to be their home; their political concerns tend to the insular or the lofty. The Union of Grinnell Student Dining Workers, organized in 2016, is a rare independent undergraduate labor union. (The actual non-student dining service employees are not unionized.) This last year, most campus activism was devoted to an unsuccessful campaign to persuade the school’s board of trustees to divest from fossil fuel companies.

What's wrong with those kids?

It was Grinnell alumni who brought the debate to campus. Shortly after Mr. Brownell became president of the N.R.A., Alana K. Smart, a 1968 Grinnell graduate, raised the question of whether the school, founded by an abolitionist, ought to accept money from the family.

Let's think about this for a minute, most gun restrictions are holdovers from Jim Crow and are attempts to prevent minorities and the poor from legal access to rightful guns, any abolitionist worth their salt in 2018 ought to be working to abolish the last vestiges of slavery in the US which are our gun and drug prohibition laws. Why would an abolitionist ever work against civil rights?

Ms. Smart, a chairwoman of Colorado Faith Communities United to End Gun Violence, discovered that the Brownells had made a named gift in to the college in 2014. Their gift helped create the Ignite Program, a community engagement effort that brings local elementary and high school students to campus.

Another "Ms" from out of state.

Ms. Smart and her classmates formed a group called Concerned Alumni of Grinnell College and set about expressing their concerns to the school. In October, members of the campus community learned about the alumni reaction through reporting in the student newspaper. This caught the attention of some faculty members.

After a campus meeting to discuss the college’s gift acceptance policy, in January, the board of trustees adopted some modest changes. Now the college may consider “the source of funds” in gift acceptance and may invite “relevant campus constituencies” to screen proposals for directed gifts.

Wow, they really stuck it to the man! That's showing the power of this sort of activism.

In June 2018, representatives of the Concerned Alumni group, on campus for their 50th reunion, delivered a petition to the college on behalf of 500 signatories. They asked the college to reject further gifts from Mr. Brownell, because he represents the N.R.A.’s “deleterious impacts on the quality of American life.”

At the meeting, Raynard S. Kington, the president of Grinnell College, declined this prospect of vetting individual donors’ affiliations before accepting gifts, calling it logistically onerous and ethically murky.

That was very polite of him, I would have called it "fucking retarded".

Mr. Kington, appointed in 2014, has previously suggested that the disagreement over the donation is part of the college’s educational commitment to facilitating civil debate over conflicting viewpoints. (“Grinnellians,” campus marketing copy reads, “ask hard questions and question easy answers.”)

Good, that explains why the students are not pushing for gun control efforts.

These particular hard questions may be a source of frustration for some at the college, according to Alice Herman, a 2018 Grinnell graduate and an editor of The Scarlet and Black, the student newspaper. She covered a trustees meeting last fall, just after the publication of a story about the college’s relationship with Mr. Brownell.

She was chastised by members of the administration during a break in the meeting, she said, for her reporting. She was approached by Angela Voos, the vice president for strategic planning and Mr. Kington’s chief of staff.

“‘Really? Again?’” Ms. Herman said Ms. Voos said, as she waved a copy of the newspaper. Ms. Voos complained that the story’s characterization of Mr. Brownell as “‘a major benefactor of college and community programs and organizations’” was “‘misleading.’” Mr. Kington, Ms. Herman said, joined the conversation to agree.

Ms. Voos told The New York Times that her memory of the episode is different, but that “the basis of the interaction is correct.” Ms. Herman, she said, “chose to combine a donor’s philanthropy to the college with his philanthropy to the local community and then to conclude that he is a ‘major benefactor’ of the college.” (Ms. Voos added that the Ignite program also had other internal funding sources.)

LOL What a lot of drama in the professor's lounge!

In any event, the college says it cannot legally disclose the details of individual contributions without permission from the donor. It is possible that Mr. Brownell and Ms. Redmond have made or will make additional gifts under different disclosure conditions.

Ms. Willis argued that accepting Brownell’s money is effectively an endorsement of the N.R.A. “The college confers legitimacy by taking that donation,” she said, contravening the institution’s professed commitment to social justice. (Mr. Rebelsky and many other faculty members said they disagreed.)

I like it when they start to eat each other.

Ms. Willis also noted that the college, committed to improved town-gown relations, had much to gain by accepting a donation to start a program “aiming to educate kids in this community that aren’t the children of college professors.”

The college, Ms. Voos said, is proud of the program: “We see it as an extension of our mission to our local public schools.” She notes that about a third of local elementary and high school students live in households that are eligible for free or reduced price lunch, and few have had much exposure to “the college experience,” even in this college town. The program has just finished its fourth year.

In other ways, the college and Brownells Inc. share similar goals as stewards of the local economy. City administrators have pinned their hopes for a revitalized downtown on both. In 2014, the city and the Brownells company jointly applied for funds from the Iowa Economic Development Authority.

They were unsuccessful, but the city and the college received joint funding the following year, which was partly to support what the school calls its “Zone of Confluence” project. A two-lane highway that divides the campus and the downtown area has long been a physical manifestation of the town-gown divide. The college and city government hope that investing in this area will connect the campus to the community and bring more money downtown. Here, it seems, everyone agrees.

The Narrative of Liberalism

While he has not accepted — or rejected — invitations to speak with his neighbors, Mr. Brownell has, in his public role, spoken about them. Many of his remarks to N.R.A. members have traded on stereotypes about liberals. To the considerable anger of these neighbors, he positioned himself as the bemused and indulgent teacher of big-city professor types.

Apparently much to the chagrin of big city professor types!!

In a 2010 profile that appeared on an N.R.A. website, Mr. Brownell took credit for creating what he called “a gun culture” at the college and for educating Grinnell students and faculty members about firearms. “Previous anti-gun sentiment at the college has been offset by an open-mindedness that never would have existed without a little push from Pete,” the story said.

God bless this man, he should be sainted.

In a 2011 interview posted on the N.R.A. YouTube channel, Mr. Brownell said that the students “have never really broken through those things that somebody told them at a young age, and they’ve never really experimented with changing their thoughts about just a larger picture.”

What’s more, he said, he had turned “a couple of New York City professors” into gun enthusiasts who visit shooting ranges when they travel. “These trips are ‘Let’s go to the Metropolitan Opera and on the way let’s take our pistols.’”

Wow, is there anything he can't do?

Few people had even seen these remarks until Ms. Smart unearthed them last year. Mr. Kington, the college president, agreed in June to denounce Mr. Brownell’s statements about taking giddy Grinnell faculty members to the shooting range.

The ones that were publicly posted on the NRA website were "unearthed"? Oh, wow, things are serious now, we are past sad faced sign tweets, strongly worded letters and Facebook invitations, now there is denouncing going on! Denouncing is like the strongest thing a social justice warrior can do short of vandalizing Trump's walk of fame star. She is denouncing him having taken people to the range?

No one I spoke to had any idea who he might have been talking about, nor did they remember Mr. Brownell ever coming to campus to discuss these issues. But they would not necessarily object if he did. Lecturing about “something he has expertise on,” like the Second Amendment, Ms. Willis said, “would be completely keeping within an academic institution, the idea of critical thinking, all of that.”

Well if none of the lesbians at the coffee shop were there then it probably didn't happen, denounce that motherfucker!

Every Town Is Three Towns

All paths actually don’t cross at Saints Rest. Anyone in Grinnell will tell you that there are three kinds of people in town: the college students, the “College people” — faculty, staff and the white-collar professionals in that orbit, which even includes clergy like Ms. Klepfer and Ms. Abrahamson — and “everyone else.”

And yet she has decided to call only one sort of those people "his neighbors" and pretended that they represent the town and not the lefty cuckoos in town who are all from out of town.

There’s another early-morning kaffeeklatsch at the Hardees across Highway 146, just outside of downtown. At lunchtime, farm-to-table Prairie Canary is a popular Main Street lunch spot, but lots of people head to the West Side Family Restaurant a mile away.

Twice she used the word "kaffeeklatsch"? C'mon honey.

“College people” have been the most involved in these debates. They recognize that they need to bring “everyone else” into the conversation — Grinnell natives, farmers, blue-collar workers, Brownells employees, hospital staff — but have so far struggled to connect.

“There are certainly people on both extremes that want to make an issue out of this,” said Mr. Behrens, the city manager. But “most people in Grinnell go about their daily business. They’re glad Brownells is here, they’re glad the college is here.” Whatever political conflict there might be “never really surfaces.”

Some people do cut cross all the cultures. Molly Miller’s maternal grandparents owned both a farm in Poweshiek County and a diner downtown. She grew up in Iowa City, but she and her sister attended Grinnell College, and she lives and works in town.

Ms. Miller, too, likes the Brownells. She also says their family’s comfort comes at the expense of her family’s own. In November 1991, her mother, Ann Rhodes, was a vice president at the University of Iowa when a physics graduate student shot and killed three department faculty members and a postdoctoral researcher and injured two administrators in another building, before killing himself. Ms. Rhodes, who was also the university’s spokeswoman and tasked with handling the aftermath, was among the first to come upon a wounded colleague, who died the following day.

Did that guy buy his guns from Brownells or is this another totally unrelated incident? Did they profit somehow from that because she claims that their "comfort" comes from her families tragedy, but what is the connection? Oh yeah there is none.

Ms. Miller was just an infant at the time. She grew up knowing that the shooting had a lasting effect on her mother’s physical and mental health, and on her family.

And she blamed gun sellers in general instead of the murderer? How does that work? Isn't that like someone blaming Ford for their loved one being killed by a drunk driver?

“I’m going to inherit my family’s farm,” she said. “But if my family’s farm was responsible for the deaths of thousands of people every year, I think I would find a different livelihood.”

Actually heart disease, caused by the products of her families farm, is the leading cause of death in America, but it does not kill thousands, it kills hundreds of thousands, the blood is on your hands Ms. Miller! In fact Brownells is not responsible for any deaths at all.

Beers and Bump Stocks

At the Fraternal Order of the Eagles club, I settled in for a beer ($1.75 a pint, frosted mug!) next to Steve Hardeman and his friends Teresa Coon and Roger Van Donselaar. Dr. Coon is a family physician, and engaged to Mr. Van Donselaar, a Grinnell native who has owned a farm for over 30 years. Mr. Hardeman, too, is a native who works in farming.

Her name is racist!

Mr. Hardeman and Mr. Van Donselaar both grew up around firearms. Dr. Coon only recently relocated to Grinnell after more than two decades in the Quad Cities region of northwest Illinois and southeastern Iowa, a metropolitan area of nearly 400,000 people, where she ran a women’s health medical practice for 25 years.

Mr. Van Donselaar was pleasantly surprised when she managed to get him to have dinner at Prairie Canary. Ms. Coon does not share their views on firearms, which she cheerfully contested while jabbing Mr. Hardeman on the arm for emphasis. He was quite patient with this, up to a point.

No one at the bar made fun of me when I timidly mentioned bump-fire stocks. (These accessories modify a semiautomatic weapon to simulate the firing rate of an automatic.) Shortly after the Las Vegas shooting, where a dozen bump stocks were found in the gunman’s hotel room, retailers like Walmart and Cabela’s stopped carrying them.

False, bump stocks do not make a semi automatic weapon into a fully automatic one.

Pages cached by the internet Archive and Google show that Brownells also removed the products from their online inventory sometime after Sept. 29, 2017; a company representative did not respond to a request to confirm the products’ removal.

Since then, several states have passed laws banning them, and the Justice Department has said it may reverse a 2010 decision and ban them under federal law. In May, Slide Fire Solutions, the largest bump stock manufacturer, which holds a patent on the devices, closed operations. (Its inventory is still being sold online.)

Hey, remember those second amendment supporters who aren't coming after your guns? I got a letter in the mail from my attorney general saying if I owned any bump stocks that I would be committing a felony. What a stupid concept, as if a bump stock is needed for bump fire, it is not. When they banned them in my state they claimed it would prevent mass shootings despite the face that we don't have any mass shootings here and the fact that as far as we know such stocks have only been used in one mass shooting so every other mass shooting occurred without using bump stocks, those would not have been prevented with a bump stock ban. Nor would the Vegas shooting, Dianne Feinstein said no law would have prevented that.

For gun control advocates, this seems like a victory, and it may be — or it may not. State and local bump stock bans face legal challenges, and local ordinances banning the devices in Ohio have been overturned.

Good, these laws are foolish.

More to the point, Mr. Hardeman said that he or most anyone at the bar could rig a semiautomatic firearm to simulate an automatic fire rate in 15 minutes, no bump stock needed. Brownells continues to carry parts and accessories that achieve similar results, including binary trigger modification parts, which ship to 44 states.

Now this guy knows what he is talking about, why did she waste her time talking to lesbian preachers?

Mr. Hardeman told me a familiar story. He is proud that he was able to contribute to his impoverished household in his boyhood by hunting small game. When he hears that gun owners are irresponsible, he tells me, he’s affronted. To him, his neighbors are lumping him and his friends in with a group to which they don’t belong. He said it seems impossible to talk with them. “Liberals want to take my guns,” he said.

Yup, right again sir.

Virtually everyone in Grinnell has taken great care to say that they do not want to take anyone’s guns. This includes Ms. Abrahamson and Ms. Scott, who says that the distinction between gun control and gun safety matters. “Many of us are gun owners,” Ms. Scott said. “We don’t want to challenge the Second Amendment. We just want to know if there’s safety where there are guns. This is not an anti-movement.”

They just want to know if there is safety where there are guns? What does that mean? A second ago Ms. Shine was asking about banning gun stocks.

“But it’s what I hear all the time,” Mr. Hardeman said, throwing up his hands.

Before I could ask, the bartender set another frosted mug in front of me. “No, someone else got it for you,” she said when I tried to pay.

When Do We Talk?

After all this not talking, few people seem to have thought about what they might actually say to Pete Brownell. “People keep telling me they want to have a conversation,” said Don A. Smith, an emeritus professor of history, emphasizing the last three words. “When I ask them what they wish to have a conversation about, they say they don’t know!”

That's typical, that is because anti gun folks don't have any actual solutions to the problems they are upset about because they refuse to honestly look at suicide, homicide and accidents as separate things.

Many people I spoke to brought up the concept of “Iowa nice” in our conversations. During my visit, I ferried four hardy senior ladies back downtown after a protest across the highway from Brownells. I asked them whether there’s any difference between Iowa, Midwestern and Minnesota nice. Everyone laughed, and someone piped up from the back seat, “No, but ours is better!”

That must have been quite a clown car.

“Iowa nice” could be the solution or the problem. The social contracts of small-town life seem rather less sturdy these days. No amount of moral clarity or urgency has made it possible to overcome the hurdle of getting people “on all sides” to talk to one another, even as they talk to one another about dozens of other things every day.

There is not really anything to talk about, we don't need to make any more concessions of our liberties to satisfy the irrational fears of those who fear civil rights.

“It’s painful,” Ms. Abrahamson said. “I don’t want his family hurt — and I mean in their spirit. I don’t even know if we have that kind of effect on them or not. But I just think in a small town you just have to be more careful with each other.”

The person who circulates among and across all these local tribes with the most ease is Mr. Brownell — certainly because of his wealth, if not also because of his fluency in the cultures that collide or coexist here.

Yeah, why not make the class warfare argument while you are writing for the NYT?

Our cultural ideas about civility and respect incline his neighbors to accept his silence. While many debate their right to carry big guns or their complicity in the gun epidemic, Mr. Brownell is, it seems, the only one who does not need to answer.

"Big guns"? Their complicity? Why should he need to answer?

Ms. Willis, a fifth-generation Iowan, calls the phenomenon “Iowa polite.” And she said it had been tested. “That’s actually kind of hard to maintain, because there’s a sense of frustration that he won’t talk to us,” she said. “But we have maintained it.” Surely it can’t last.

In May, Mr. Brownell declined to serve a second year as N.R.A. president and was replaced by Oliver North. He remains a member of the organization’s board of directors. His work is not over.

Good, he is doing a heck of a job.

Last month, a group of Senate Democrats asked Mr. Brownell and six other N.R.A. leaders for details about a 2015 trip to Moscow. There, the delegation met Maria Butina, who was charged last month with being a covert Russian agent in an investigation unrelated to the probe by Robert S. Mueller, the special counsel.

LOL Russia Russia Russia!

After the Parkland, Fla., shooting in February, stickers with the Brownells logo and the text “Brownells, where school shootings are good for business” appeared on walls and fixtures across downtown Grinnell.

Note how the left's media celebrates vandalism when in support of their causes.

No one would say who was responsible for them. It was a strong breach of the oppressive contract of niceness. But it wasn’t the only speech taking place in the public sphere. On my way out of town, I heard a radio spot advertising the can’t-miss Brownells Second Amendment Sale that weekend.

Yeah at the end of the day the gun industry is beloved and generates money and the anti-gun people are hated and just spend Bloomberg's money. Good.

Wow, that was a tour de force, are you still reading? If you read through this what are your thoughts?

please vote generously and resteem, this took me all morning