Philadelphia Artist on the Frontlines

In February 1918, the U.S. Army commissioned eight artists to travel with the American Expeditionary Forces and capture the soldiers’ experience of the Great War. Among the eight artists was local Philadelphian George Matthews Harding (1882-1959) who once studied under famed artist Howard Pyle at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts.

Army personnel believed the artists’ creations could garner public support and encourage the sale of war bonds. That idea was quickly contradicted as the artists captured the grim realities of war instead of the earlier traditions of patriotic, heroic scenes.

George Harding, American Wounded Making Way To First Aid Station In The Village Of Marne During German Attack, 1918. Harding captures the human toll of war and new innovations including the airplane and barbed wire. Image from Wikimedia Commons.

From his position in the trenches of France, Harding illustrated the new technologies of twentieth-century warfare including tanks, airplanes, and machine guns. His scenes captured the new realities of war, not the romanticized abstractions.

George Harding, Boche Plane Falling in No Man's Land of Verdun Offensive, 1918. A massive plane falls from the sky in the vicinity of a German machine gun nest. Image from Wikimedia Commons.

The majority of Harding’s drawings captured the everyday experience of war, and the national Committee on Public Information asserted they lacked “sufficient drama.” General John Pershing, however, approved of these accurate depictions and argued only the men serving in France could determine what qualified as “sufficient drama.” (1)

George Harding, 26th Division, 1918. Image from WWI Online.

Like all the soldier artists, Harding turned the active battlefield into his personal studio. He made sketches and took notes while he experienced live enemy fire, the unpredictable weather, and the emotionally distressing elements of trench life. He referred to his “studio” as, “the loneliest place in the world.” (2)

George Harding, Going Thro Gas, 1918. Image from WWI Online

After the war, Harding returned to Philadelphia where he published his personal portfolio including thirty-eight drawings and notes. More than 500 copies of The American Expeditionary Forces in Action were sold and exposed a larger public to the World War One experience. (3)

During the WW1 centennial, Harding’s work has recently received greater attention. Last year, the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts opened their exhibit, World War One and American Art, which was "the first major exhibition devoted to exploring the ways in which American artists reacted to the First World War." The National Air and Space Museum currently has their Artist Soldiers exhibit which compares Harding's and other artist soldiers' work with the extemporaneous carvings by soldiers found throughout the European trenches.

Despite the new popularity of photography during the war, Harding's work is still relevant to the study of WW1. Why do you think the Army commissioned artists despite their subjective nature? What can this art provide that photography cannot? Are drawings more or less subjective than photography? Let me know what you think!

Resources:

1. Vincent Fraley, “Artists in Uniform,”WWI Online,published June 27, 2014, accessed February 13, 2018.
2. Alfred Cornebise, Art From the Trenches : America's Uniformed Artists in World War I, (College Station: Texas A&M University Press, 2014), 32-35.
3. Ibid.

---

^{100% of the SBD rewards from this #explore1918 post will support the Philadelphia History Initiative @phillyhistory. This crypto-experiment conducted by graduate courses at Temple University's Center for Public History and MLA Program, is exploring history and empowering education. Click here to learn more.}