Has Google Begun To Rewire Our Brains?

in #technology6 years ago

Hey Steemians

So when I'm not interacting on Steemit, believe it or not, I do have a day job. Which revolves around optimising websites to improve their visibility on Google and no not with paid ads. I'm referring to the actual organic listings you click on when you perform a search. This discipline is known as SEO and very few people know about it and even fewer people give a shit about it.

In fact, when I tell people that's what I do for a living they would say something like but doesn't Google just work by itself with algorithms and bots and machine learning. Yes in a sense it does but its pretty rudimentary at this stage and needs help from guys and girls like us to make sure search remains as relevant as possible.

It's a selfless job but someones gotta make sure you find that find the cheapest flights, or that pasta recipe or how to find the closest KFC in your area (Yes South African's I'm talking to you on this one. Why is this our most popular search term for 2017? WHY???!)

Google search

Fascination with peoples questions & behaviours

Googling or rather using search has become a very personal experience for some its just a wham bam think you ma'am give me what I want. While for others its a slow foreplay, light some candles, put on some music and we're going to do all sorts of searches in the comfort of your own home.

Looking at search data all damn day in big ass spreadsheets that often crash and lead me to tears does take me down some of the strangest paths. Looking at peoples search queries, the way the search, the words and phrases they use, where they're searching from can be very entertaining if you have the patience for it, but also a window into the intermate experiences people have with searching for information online.

As I've been studying the data and trends for years I've noticed how reliant people have become on search engines. It has become an almost symbiotic relationship and people place way too much faith in the results returned without questioning them.

This sort of behaviour I feel has begun to rewire the way our brains work, especially the younger generation who never had the opportunity to explore alternative means of finding information. How many kids today do you think Googled "Library near me", probably not many!

Back in the day

Before the internet or before search was so popular and advanced if someone asked you a tricky question, you had a couple of options.

  • You could see if anyone you knew had the answer.
  • You could pull out an encyclopedia. (I miss Encarta and Brittanica so much)
  • You could head down to the library to carry out research.

Whichever one you opted for, it was almost certainly more complicated and time-consuming than what you’d do today: Google it.

Thanks to this technology we've become spoilt we don't even have to remember the correct spelling anymore just throw some random words into a field click search and more often than not it spits out what you're looking for.

It's brilliant and convenient but with all these comforts and advantages at our fingertips, are we not beginning to outsource our memory, problem-solving and more cognitive thought to the internet?

Our virtual brain

The answer seems to be a resounding yes, according to recent research. The latest study, from academics at the universities of California and Illinois, found that our increasing reliance on the internet is transforming the way we think and remember.

In the study, two groups of people were asked to answer a set of trivia questions. Those in the first group were told to use only their memories, while the others had to look up the answers online. Both groups were then asked a set of easier questions and given the option of using the internet. Those who had used the internet the first time round were much more likely to do so again.

Not only were they more likely to refer to the internet, but they were also quicker to do so, making very little attempt to figure out the answer themselves, even when the questions were relatively simple.

All of this is evidence of a trend the researchers refer to as “cognitive offloading”. It has become so easy to just look something up online, we’re giving up even trying to remember certain things.

“Whereas before we might have tried to recall something on our own, now we don’t bother. As more information becomes available via smartphones and other devices, we become progressively more reliant on it in our daily lives,” Benjamin Storm, the study’s lead author, said.

How the internet changes our brains

This latest study builds on existing research that suggests the internet isn’t just changing how we live and work – it’s actually altering our brains.

For anyone familiar with the work of neuroscientist Michael Merzenich, this won’t come as a surprise. After all, that’s what our brain is made to do. “It’s constructed for change. It’s all about change,” he explains in his popular TED talk.

The more important question, then, is whether or not this is a good thing. “It seems pretty clear that memory is changing,” Storm told us. “But is it changing for the better? At this point, we don’t know.”

Indeed, opinion seems divided as to whether this is a positive or negative development.

Some argue that by removing the need for learning – a system under which we were forced to memorize dates, names and facts – the internet has helped free up cognitive resources for other, more important things.

Nicholas Carr, the author of What the internet is doing to our brains, isn’t so optimistic.

By relying on the internet as an external hard drive for our memory, we are losing the ability to transfer the facts we hear and read on a daily basis from our working memory to our long-term one – something Carr describes as “essential to the creation of knowledge and wisdom”.

“Dozens of studies by psychologists, neurobiologists and educators point to the same conclusion: when we go online, we enter an environment that promotes cursory reading, hurried and distracted thinking, and superficial learning,” he writes.

From post-it notes to iPhones

While much more research into the consequences of this remains to be done, perhaps the change isn’t as significant as we might think.

After all, as technology writer Clive Thompson points out, we’ve actually been outsourcing our memory for a long time.

“Humanity has always relied on coping devices to handle the details for us. We’ve long stored knowledge in books and on paper and post-it notes.” It’s just that today, we turn to more sophisticated tools for that helping hand. “You can stop worrying about your iPhone moving your memory outside your head. It moved out a long time ago,” Thompson says.

And for Storm and the team of researchers behind this latest study, that might not be such a bad thing.

“In the end I’m, fairly optimistic. I think the internet (and technology more generally) is going to greatly expand the capabilities of the human mind.”

With great power comes great responsibility

My personal feeling on the subject is that it is going to have a negative effect on the way we use our brains, cognitive offloading needs to be handled with care as it can quickly encourage information bias, misinformation and the distribution of propaganda.

We need to teach people to use Google/Search responsible and how to decern facts, opinions and what is reliable information. How to evaluate information and encourage them to review counter arguments and not just accept information presented to them as commandments. To use Google search has become in my opinion a vice of society, and like any nice, alcohol, sex, gambling it can be helpful and fun but in moderation. It needs to be used in the right mindset and to be used responsibly.

Yes, it's time to take personal responsibility and not always pointing fingers at CEOS of tech companies pushing their profit agendas on us.

Look we can talk all day about Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Larry & Sergi, the Zuck and all the silicon valley pioneers who helped shape this digital age. They are smart dudes don't get me wrong but good old Uncle Ben's words of wisdom will always stand the test of time in my book. If it was good enough for Peter Parker, then it's good enough for me!

Have at it

What do you think of Google rewriting our brains?
Do you think it frees us up to be more creative and gives us more brain power to focus on more complex issues?
Or is it stripping us from using our brains more often and keeping it as sharp as possible by constantly challenging it?

Do you trust Google results? Have you ever questioned them before? Do you look at anything after the top 3 lists? Have you ever been to page 2? Do you use alternative search tools like Bing or DuckDuck Go? I'd love to hear how you use search!

Holla at your boy in the comments!

Let's connect

If you liked this post sprinkle it with an upvote or resteem and if you don't already, consider following me @chekohler
follow me


Put your votes to good use

We all can't max out our upvotes every day and a little help never hurt. Sign up to Smartsteem and sell a few of your votes each day, earn some STEEM and SBD in the process and still get in some curation rewards in STEEM Power. Check out SmartSteem


Trade Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, Doge or Dash for STEEM instantly

Check out blocktrades to quickly exchange popular cryptocurrencies for STEEM, STEEM power or STEEM Dollars or trade your STEEM, STEEM power or STEEM dollars for popular cryptocurrencies


Sources:

Sort:  

Great article! I think part of the problem is that the nature of information sharing and network effects is to create a "winner take all" dynamic. McDonald's can be the biggest fast food chain, but there is still room for Burger King. Search and social media, on the other hand, guarantee that #1 stays #1 and there's no reason to ever use the 2nd biggest search engine or 2nd biggest social network, at least for most casual Internet users.
You probably know better than anyone that the top search result is positioned to get the most clicks, and this creates a positive feedback loop, ensuring that results further down the list never see the light of day.
I'm not sure what the answer is. I don't think blockchain or other tools of decentralization would fix it, because even the simplest algorithm of ranking by clicks results in this scenario every time.
Getting rid of the sponsored ads would be a good start, though.

Gosh sorry for the late reply I only saw this comment now trying to create a steem forever post lol!I completely agree with your thoughts on this it is a winner take all and funnelling people and their thoughts not to the most accurate information but the ones that give the quickest answers, simplest answers and meet today's internet users instant gratification expectations and as opposed to quality and this feedback loop continues

As for fixing it I also dont think there is a technology that can compete with these guys let alone have people adopt it, they will marginalise you even if you had a great idea. The only way around it is providing some sort of education so people can see the results they get for what they are, understand the context and don't just think the top 3 results or whats in their news feed is the 10 commandments. A bit idealistic perhaps we will just continue to move into a world were the rest don't think they absorb what the outliers create

To the question in your title, my Magic 8-Ball says:

As I see it, yes

Hi! I'm a bot, and this answer was posted automatically. Check this post out for more information.

That was a good post. In Sweden we can see that "content is king" more today than only for 1 year ago. Special after this medicupdate. Do you have a blog about seo at your buisness? Or only blog at steemit?

Posted using Partiko Android

Thanks man, glad you enjoyed it! Yes that’s right Individual pages content will become even more important now with the introduction of E-A-T from the last algorithm update so we should see a big shift in the search results, especially with localized search

Yes I blog about SEO and digital marketing on this blog - https://www.nichemarket.co.za/blog/

Posted using Partiko iOS

Thanks. I will check it out. I only read SEO-blogpost when I know who has written them. I do not know why but it feels better to know the sender.
Here is my http://www.skribentus.se/contentisking/ I think it is only the latest post that is about EAT. Not blogging so much but it happen and most with fokus at hte swedish market.
But I will absolulty read yours to see get "new eyes" and thoughts. I first of all a content writer but like to work a little with seo too. See you. Have to go out now a couple of hours and hunt crystals (wordopo game)

I think it’s all part of the overall plan to control the masses; when people can’t remember things without searching they forget important stuff like history. They then need to do an internet search and what comes up in those searches? What is designed for you to remember. Example would be 9/11. Our generations know it was a load of shit, false pretenses and debauchery. They hear me talk about it and tell them that, forget what I said and google it. Good chance that the governments version of terrorism, American heroics, osama bin laden a killer and so on. They would never try to see that millions of innocent people were slaughtered and continue to be slaughtered because of those false pretenses. It’s designed to dumb people down over time. There’s certainly some good to it yes but there is also lots of bad.

I can totally see that happening and that’s such a great example you gave to illustrate your answer!

Instead of being a gateway to information google has become an echo chamber of curated content like Instagram and because of its brand recognition it’s trusted and hardly questioned

The continued gamification of search will cause more problems than solutions eventually but for now I’ll rate it as 50/50

Posted using Partiko iOS

It's true google has been changing our mindset and the way we think but on the other hand it has been making things easier for us. Searching for a problem or meaning of something is no longer too difficult for us.

Hey dude, dont forget to share some of your knowledge about SEO to me. Remember!

Yes that’s true but we’re attributing to much value to google and not looking at what it produces in the proper context! Google is in a unique position where it sorts information but takes no responsibility for misinformation

To many users take results verbatim and trust it without a second thought! It’s made people lazy

I feel we should actually have a course on how to google and how to evaluate the data you’re given

Sure drop me your questions in discord or check out my SEO blog link is in my bio

Posted using Partiko iOS

You are absolutely right. Some of the information are misrepresented and these information were written by people like us!

Perhaps we should be more careful while searching for information through google and not rely totaly on it.

I have seen that you are in a contest where to guess value of ripple and more coins. One comment at that contest is Always that they are at blacklist. Do you still think it is a good contest. I use to enter before

Posted using Partiko Android

I just saw it in my feed so I thought I’d give it a try, doesn’t hurt to comment so let’s see what happens

Posted using Partiko iOS

One habit I have while writing is to quickly Google a word when I get a spellcheck but I don't see the issue. I do this to check that I spelled the word correctly, and that it has the definition I was thinking of. Something like 95% of the time, my initial usage was both correct in definition and spelling. Maybe I should stop doing this, if it's hurting my memory capabilities.

I do the exact same things from time to time and there are many great use cases for google! It’s more the over reliance on it and the never questioning the validity of the results given!

It would an interesting experiment now that you mention it! A day without using google how would it change the way you do things

Posted using Partiko iOS

This post has received a 4.55 % upvote from @boomerang.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.28
TRX 0.13
JST 0.032
BTC 60913.71
ETH 2919.21
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.71