You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Manifesto For A Governed Blockchain
Hi, great essay that you have put out here, you address very important topics of current socio economic challenges.
There are two things that I don't understand:
How is would the v2 constitution be inline with the governance you call for? In my view it's the complete opposite, promoting the law of the jungle and paving the way for powerful dapps, to enforce governance to their liking and sole benefit. @thecastle has done a great analysis of this problem recently.
- How will the Eos foundation be implemented on chain, and evade problems that arose with defacto self appointed entities like ecaf etc?
Anyhow valuable contribution, happy to resteem!
https://dlive.io/video/thecastle/6963f591-9cc0-11e8-b91a-0242ac110003
This is a link to the video that @conceptskip is talking about. Basically we have a situation where dapps coins have to chose to be either hyper political or face never reaching mass adoption.
I think V2 and Dan's plans for dapp layer governance are really quite consistent with this manifesto. But I got a bit speculative - just exploring. Wrt the Eos foundation/alliance I admittedly am sceptical too but since Thomas was asking for perspectives I thought I might as well try to put some thoughts down. As a challenge. Thanks for the resteem @conceptskip! Btw I've been enjoying your posts. Your restaurant reviews are a great addition to your Eos articles!
As for dapp layer governance I just don't see it, and i didn't find an explanation anywhere. I wouldn't say I am sceptical towards the foundation attempt, it's what this community direly needs, eventually any entity would need to be elected, wouldn't they. Thanks for your words, always try to remain a bit grounded too...
I did try to write it in the most idealistic way that I could, in true manifesto style! But yes, I'm not the most grounded of people, that's fair. Thanks for the reminder
Don't get me wrong, I really think your manifesto is brilliant! It perfectly describes our current situation and the right direction onwards. I could have never written this essay, so in that sense, glad you are not grounded ;)