You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Top 50 Role Playing Games from RPG Codex
I agree on this list for the most part, with one exception. Why isn't the first KOTOR game higher up on here? I personally enjoyed KOTOR II quite a bit and love it, but it has a very meh ending since it was so rushed and never quite finished. I would definitely only place it maybe 2-4 spots ahead of KOTOR I. Besides that little gripe, everything else is pretty solid though!
Generally people from codex like the 2nd one better because it has that darker and more mature tone. You can also notice Arcanum and Bloodlines are in top 10, both games had that unfinished feel about them, but in terms of overall quality, storytelling and gameplay they ended up on top. It depends if the story and setting can hold the game together people tend to forgive that unfinished part.
I guess. As much as I loved the second game the ending/endings was a big let down and I wouldn't have left it so far ahead of the first KOTOR game at all. Though I suppose with the mod they put out it at least made the ending more tolerant. Either way, this is just my opinion. I can understand why it's higher than the first KOTOR game at the very least :P