👨‍👩‍👧‍👧 Khmerican Family Abroad | #6 - 🏖️Expat or 🏃🏿Immigrant❓

in #travelfeed5 years ago (edited)

The words "expat," "immigrant" and "migrant" mean very different things to different people.


🕵️ | BY DEFINITION | 📚


     First, let's get the dictionary definitions out of the way before jumping in too deep. Below is a list of these three words and their definitions.

Word
Merrian Webster Definition
expatriate (n.)
(1) a person who lives in a foreign country
immigrant (n.)
(1️) a person who comes to a country to take up permanent residence; (2) a plant or animal that becomes established in an area where it was previously unknown
migrant (n.)
(1) a person who moves regularly in order to find work especially in harvesting crops; (2) an animal that shifts from one habitat to another


✈️ | A WORD OF PRIVILEGE | 💰


     "Expat" is a word I had never even heard until about 10 years ago. Call it naivety or ignorance, but I had never encountered a so-called expat growing up in the countryside of Indiana. Well, at least the Mexicans, Haitians, Guatemalans and Jamaicans that I knew in the USA never referred to themselves using this word.

Sakana living up to her moniker - Monkey B 🐵

     It was 2010 in a touristy part of Siem Reap when I first overheard someone say the word expat while walking down a narrow alley. I didn't ponder it's meaning much until I had heard the word hundreds of more times over several months. I was new and green in the world of living abroad, so I had much to learn and didn't want to bother anyone by asking too many questions.

     My reason for moving to Cambodia in 2010 was to escape poverty and try to improve the general quality of my life. After hearing English teaching was the easiest job to get, I put in applications at all the international schools. I thought surely I'd find work quickly, but after a few weeks I began to think my turban, beard, lack of a college degree and ESL teacher qualifications were preventing school directors from taking a risk by hiring me. I would eventually find work at lower-tier schools where my coworkers were mostly Cambodians, Filipinas and Nigerians.

A typical day after work at school - flooding is no good reason to cancel 🌊

     After some months teaching in Cambodia, I realized I was in two different social worlds. One social group was mostly Filipinas, Nigerians and Cambodians, and the other was mostly Americans, Europeans and Australians. I had my foot in both worlds, but tended to spend more time with the former. The Americans, Europeans and Australians tended to refer to themselves as "expats", and the Nigerians and Filipinas didn't seem to call themselves anything other their nationality. I didn't have a preference for either group, but the Nigerians and Filipinas knew how to go out on a budget similar to mine, so I knew it was safer to hang out with them.

     I eventually began to realize the word expat seemed very loaded. I had not liked using the word to refer to myself, but knew Cambodian citizenship was not an option for me, so immigrant was also an incorrect term. I was certainly not a migrant, because I didn't intend to go anywhere else. I began to realize the word expat was applied to working professionals, those wealthy enough not to work and those who could afford to choose how much they worked.

🥼 | AN EXPERIMENT DEVISED | 🧪


     I decided I would conduct an experiment to see if I was really this naive. I had been referring to my Nigerian and Filipina friends as expats because I didn't know what else to call them; they too, like me, were ineligible to become Cambodian citizens. I would put this to the test by having a dinner party at my house (prison cell-sized room). I invited several Nigerian and Filipina coworkers, and told them some "westerner" friends were also going to come. I told the "westerner" friends some other "expat" friends would also be coming. There wasn't much more to it than that; things had been put into action. Time to cook, prepare for house guests and probably an interesting conversation.

👨‍🍳 A cook is more useful in the kitchen than in the classroom anyways 👨‍🏫

     It only took a few minutes after guests arrived to realize my naivety. The westerner friends were quite surprised to see half the party was black and brown. They did well enough to hide their astonishment by engaging in awkward conversation, but it was enough for me to realize the power of words. It was obvious enough the westerner friends had assumed the other expats were white, or at least from wealthy countries. Had I referred to the other dinner guests as "immigrants", I'm sure there would've been some extra questions.

🧻 | THE DIRTY WORDS | 💩


     Of the dirty words, "immigrant" and "migrant", migrant has certainly become more demonized in recent years. Neither word seems to come with a positive connotation, especially in these Trumpian times we are living in. There is an ever-increasing surge of nationalism and anti-immigrant/migrant sentiment growing around the world. Even here in Suriname where I now live, there is a wave of Haitian hysteria brewing.

Dinner with my Cambodian neighbors in a very typical scenario 🍽️

     The word "immigrant" is often associated with people from lower economic classes doing jobs that aren't necessarily respected, skilled or high-paying. In Indiana, my homestate in the USA, immigrant seems to also mean the person doesn't speak English. Pardon the pun, but either way you stack it, the word immigrant is loaded with negative stigma. I think now it could even be argued that the word immigrant is also generally associated with crime, poverty and drugs.

     "Migrant" subconsciously screams "STRANGER DANGER!" The first thought most non-woke people have when they hear migrant is hungry and needy people on foot in groups. I won't deny there are plenty of hungry and needy migrants around the world, but the word doesn't need to immediately conjure negative thoughts. Many cultures around the world are nomadic, which means they are in a constant state of migration. What's so dangerous about somebody being somehwere for an unknown amount of time?

Me riding a motodup between Aranyaprathet & Poipet - a popular Cambodian migrant route to Thailand 🏍️

🗺️ | GOING FORWARD | 🔮


     I've now changed how I approach and use these terms. Whether or not the person has a good sense of humor determines how far I'll take it. When in social situations with entitled expat types, I make sure to ask them if they are an immigrant too. I try to have fun with it, and every now and then it sparks a good conversation.

     In general though, I now refer to all immigrants as expats in casual conversation. Language changes with the times, so I try to adapt. When I visit the USA, I like to test phrases like "I know some Thai expats that have a really good restaurant. Do you want to go?" and "The Chinese grocery store has the best prices, all the expats go there." As long as I get weird stares when I say things like this, I know not much has changed.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

Are you an expat, immigrant or migrant, and what do these terms mean to you?

Please tell me in the comments below.


Follow @justinparke, upvote and resteem if you like this post.

View this post on TravelFeed for the best experience.

Sort:  

It's very interesting to learn about this. Where you are also looks like a nice place!

Thanks for writing this comment through TravelFeed.io!
You have received a 10% upvote from us. We hope to see you soon on TravelFeed.io!

Yes, I think there is a lot of colonial mentality wrapped up in the word "expat." I'm not the first person to write about the subject by any means, but I just wanted to give my take on it. I realize many Steemians live abroad and thought it may be food for thought.

We've moved to Valencia Spain and it bugs me when other foreigners talk about being an expat .. so I love talking about that we became immigrants to Spain 10 years ago and I love going to immigrant meet-ups! Heheh!

Thanks for writing this comment through TravelFeed.io!
You have received a 6% upvote from us. We hope to see you soon on TravelFeed.io!

And those nomadic laptop warriors, they are technically "migrants." I have dared to call westerners this word only a few times, and it was never taken kindly. However, like you said, I'm okay with vocabulary too. I tell westerners we are migrants with immigration dreams, and we generally get blank stares. I can tell the wheels are turning as they ponder

"How can a white guy be a migrant?".

"How can a white guy be a migrant?"

Woah. That exceeds all racist talking I have ever heard of.

In their defense, no one has ever physically let those words fall out of their mouth. I do however, feel I see them thinking it with their eyes.

I love this post!

I was an immigrant or expat or migrant once. From the USA to Australia. I probably felt more like an immigrant since I was there married to my Australian husband and living my life surrounded by Australian people. Expat to me always seems more temporary. Like all the Aussies or South Africans working on short term Visas in Europe. They come for a few years. Make a lot of money doing casual work. Travel a lot. Spend their time with people from their home countries and then wander home in three or four years.

Now I am back in the US and my Australian husband is the immigrant. Even as a tall, blue eyed, Australian white guy being a green card holding immigrant is a stressful in trump land.

Tons of people with zero clue about immigration, the process, the rules, the emotion that accompanies living so far from home... all suddenly have very strong, uneducated and vocal opinions on the whole process. Then they look even dumber when they say.... oh but we don’t feel this way about Australians or your husband...

Why? Cause you only feel that way about the brown immigrants?

Your story about your friendship circles in Cambodia reminds me of stories I have heard about cruise ships. I have several friends who have worked on cruises and I was in a different branch of tourism for several years. Cruise ship staff are generally from all over the world. But the above deck crew are usually from more affluent countries, while the galley staff, maids and crew with less guest interaction are from less affluent counties. Seems totally sketchy.

Anyway, your post perfectly captures the nuances of living abroad.

     It's funny how strong words are isn't it? Most Americans have a hard time to even associate the word "immigrant" with white-skinned people. By definition, the word has nothing to do with wealth, but yet society has created a secondary subtle subconscious meaning.

     It's funny you mention"cruise ships" too, because I know that world all too well. I have lots of Filipino friends, and also here in Suriname our landlord's daughter is a cruise ship worker, and she has similar stories. There is certainly a caste system within that world, not only with the job types and pay scales, but also who can be granted permission and trusted to leave the ship and return at ports of call.

Congratulations, Your Post Has Been Added To The Steemit Worldmap!
Author link: http://steemitworldmap.com?author=justinparke
Post link: http://steemitworldmap.com?post=expat-or-immigrant


Want to have your post on the map too?

  • Go to Steemitworldmap
  • Click the code slider at the bottom
  • Click on the map where your post should be (zoom in if needed)
  • Copy and paste the generated code in your post
  • Congrats, your post is now on the map!

Congratulations! Your high-quality travel content was selected by @travelfeed curator @worldcapture and earned you a partial upvote. We love your hard work and hope to encourage you to continue to publish strong travel-related content.
Thank you for being part of the TravelFeed community!

Thanks for posting through TravelFeed.io! You have received a larger upvote from us. We hope to see you soon on TravelFeed.io!
Posting through TravelFeed.io also makes your post eligible to participate in the travel writing contest by @invisusmundi where you can earn up to 100 STEEM! Read the contest announcement for more information on how to participate.

We are continuously working on improving TravelFeed, recently we introduced EasySignUp and EasyLogin, our first step to make TravelFeed ready for mass adoption.


Learn more about TravelFeed by clicking on the banner above and join our community on Discord.

Woohoo! Give thanks for the Travelfeed.io platform and the hardworking team behind it.

We're giving our best! Thank you for using TravelFeed!

Nice one, I'll give a more in depth comment when I've got free time..

I've never seen anyone tag people and not catch shit for it. Not saying its guaranteed but it's likely this is hurting your post..

Posted using Partiko Android

Thanks, curious to see how those words get used where you live.

I don't know what happened with my tag list, got it sorted though. I realize I was excessive in the beginning, but I have a list of curators that generally resteeem and upvote my posts. I double-checked my list after you mentioned that, and saw tons of duplicates and other errors. Anyways, got it sorted, organized and more concise.


This post was shared in the Curation Collective Discord community for curators, and upvoted and resteemed by the @c-squared community account after manual review.
@c-squared runs a community witness. Please consider using one of your witness votes on us here

Wow! Thank you @c-squared. You provide a valuable service to undervalued posts.

Congratulations @justinparke! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You distributed more than 700 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 800 upvotes.

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

To support your work, I also upvoted your post!

Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!

Thank you @steemitboard. Yes I’ll vote for you as a witness too.

Posted using Partiko iOS

Thanks for sharing your experience with us!
TIBLogo

You have been curated by @hafizullah on behalf of Inner Blocks: a community encouraging first hand content, with each individual living their best life, and being responsible for their own well being. #innerblocks Check it out at @innerblocks for the latest information and community updates, or to show your support via delegation.

Give thanks @hafizullah and @innerblocks! I will check your page out and also remember the hashtag #innerblocks.

Interesting perspective. I am also from the US and also assumed when someone refer to a person as an expat, it ment they where financially independent and chose to live in another country. I also viewed it as way people were trying to stretch thier retirement dollars, or possible geographic arbitrage for online businesses.

I completely agree the word immigrant and migrant are loaded words, much more than in previous years. I will have to be more aware of how I view and use those words.

Posted using Partiko Android

It is weird, but there is a lot of racism built into these words. If a Filipina goes to work as house-maid in Saudi Arabia, technically she is an expat, but no one is likely to call her that. She would likely be labeled a migrant or immigrant. If that same woman is a nurse, she is still likely to not be called an expat by westerners. There are certainly some double standards because a white begpacker from the USA can go live in Cambodia in poverty for a year, but still be considered an expat before being referred to as a migrant or immigrant.

Skin color certainly has a lot to do with how you'll likely be labeled by westerners living abroad. Just food for thought is all.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.29
TRX 0.11
JST 0.033
BTC 63945.57
ETH 3135.76
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.00