You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Suggestions category - Weekly report: #2
Hello @favcau I wanted to come by and see your weekly report. Nice job on this post and great idea to have some hints on how to make a better post.
I'm wondering why the average score is so low? For example last week you had 4 posts from regular posters. Average only 61 for regular contributors. Do you think your questions are too hard or they are not producing above D- grade quality? Or did you just have one really bad post that lowered the average?
For me 61 grade is just 2 points above failure. What do you think?
Hey, thank you for passing by :)
You're right, 60 isn't high but it's a good score for the category.
And maybe we're also too strict. In the past we (Suggestions Category) had ~300 contributions per week and many people were trying to game the system.
Maybe we have to start not to be so hard in our reviews.
Another thing is that the presentation of a post could be excellent but the suggested idea not so valuable or original.
Wow I would not know what to do with 300 contributions? How did you handle it to now get it at 4 to 10 per week?. I think a category can handle maybe 4 to 8 per day. But for sure many of those would not get upvote under the new system.
It seems that it will be good to get maybe 4 or 5 a day for 4 mods.
How many mods are in your category? Are they all active?
We have 4 mods and we are all in different time zones so it is good.
The rules weren't so clear at that time and we had a lot of trivial suggestions (e.g.: Change the color of the button "Submit").
Also, suggestions per project are limited (you can not submit something that was suggested before).
And, after the hack, contributions decreased a bit.
We are 4 active mods