Response to EcoTrain's QOTW: Why do We Judge Others, and is there any value in it?

in #dtube5 years ago (edited)



▶️ DTube
▶️ IPFS

"DON'T JUDGE ME!" is often the hysterical cry of teenage girls in the classroom, whether it's when they give you an essay or have to do an oral presentation. I reassure them, tell them that they don't judge others or wish ill of others, so the likelihood of them being judged is pretty low. This is partly right - most of us are willing others to succeed and do well, but damn, teenagers are harsh. They're the judgiest of them all - no wonder they're terrified about being judged themselves!

As I say in my Dtube (don't judge me!) it's fine to make snap judgements of others - we do it all the time. See a painfully drunk guy in the bar being belligerent, and you probably want to avoid interacting. Observe a colleague being bitchy, and yeah, you might not want to go there. There is a great deal of value in being judgemental, because it helps protect and preserve our physical safety as well as the safety of our minds and souls. I have reached an age where I can make snap judgements about people and decided whether or not to get involved on the basis of it might not be good for me to do so, and might not help them at all.

image.png
Image Source

How must it feel to be judged by the colour of your skin? This campaign attempted to get Australians to empathise with the negative effects of discrimination upon indigenous Australians. Often, we're so busy thinking about ourselves that we don't stop and think about how damaging our actions and words that are based on our snap judgements might have on others

Judgements tend to go waaaay beyond the 'snap' assessment and permeate society. In indigenous Australia, high degrees of discrimination make them feel as if they're less likely to succeed, and leads to a plethora of mental health issues. We see these examples the world over. Whether you're white, black, old, skinny, a woman or a youth, you're bound to have suffered the effects of feeling judged, and that feels pretty terrible. Everyone wants to be seen, heard and valued, and to feel you have to hide an essential part of who you are lest you are judged, or you can't because your physical appearance is what it is, feels absolutely rotten.

When I was 15 or so, I was bullied pretty badly, and I still can't think of that time without feeling really ill. Sometimes, it comes back in my dreams, and we're talking over 30 years ago now. This cruel and vicious exclusionary behaviour by teenager girls shaped how I felt about myself, and whilst I've had moments of confidence in my life too, for the most part, I've felt shame about who I am and felt the need to cover it up with a facade that really necessitated ME having to be judgemental. Again, this is a survival mechanism - if I could assess how others behaved, maybe I could change part of myself so that I would fit in and belong, and feel loved. Tragic, right? Once you get stuck in that loop, you start to fear judgement pretty badly, and avoid situations that might involve rejection. Whilst rejection is part of life, that's not how it appears to someone who's been damaged by the pain of being judged just for being who they are. It takes awhile to climb out of that quagmire and sometimes you get stuck in patterns that are limiting.

Hence, me slightly freaking out about showing my face on Dtube. I've made some pretty cool friendships here that I treasure, and to me, there's something inherently risky about showing my face and worrying I'll be unloved. I know it's not rational - when I type it out, I sound a little crazy, but I think we all go through that fear because we have all experienced this feeling of being ostracized or left out or isolated or alone. @eco-alex's posting of the @ecotrain question of the week seems so timely to me because it's forcing me to look at why I'm so scared of revealing myself in this way.

The question is:

Why do people judge each other? Is there any value in it?

I think what I say above, and in the Dtube, is clear - there's only value when you need to protect yourself, but for the most part, judgement hurts.

I think we need to be vigilant about the judgements we make, and constantly enquire where they came from, and if there is any real worth to them or indeed any truth. We must ask:

  • Have I been manipulated by a story told to me by others?
  • Is this the only truth I know about this person or group of people?
  • What might be the extenuating circumstances that have caused this person to act or behave in a way that makes me judge them superficially?
  • How might I dig deeper by reaching out and asking questions?
  • How might my words or actions - or, what I don't do - impact on the other person?

Once we start doing this, we start practicing compassion, that ability to care for others and what they're going through. We can look beyond the superficial layers and find gold. We can also really prevent suffering too - just as we need to be seen and heard and loved, so do others. Think about those suicides that could have been prevented if only someone had asked: are you really okay? how are you coping? Think about the people you could have known, had connected with, if only you weren't making those assessments that stopped you going any further or any deeper.

And the real magic can happen too - if we aren't judging others in this way, it stands to reason that we can look beyond the layers of our own identities, peel them away to find the real value within our own selves, and begin a journey to a place of better self worth, self esteem and happiness.

That's the path I'm on anyway - trying to flip it around to treat myself a little more kindly, judge myself a little less. To see beyond the superficial layers and appreciate and value the real heart in me - all that love and compassion I have counts for far, far more than any snap judgements others might make about me, or the criticisms I have for my perceived failures.

I also know we can't live our lives worrying about rejection because that's just as part of life as light is to darkness. And often rejection or certain judgements can be useful, as they inform where to go next. My favourite quote of the last few years is: 'We aren't rejected, we are just re-directed'. Those kind of judgements can be useful in our development and growth. We can't expect to please everyone - that's just the way it goes. But I certainly won't waste any more energy on worrying about it, so Dtube, here I come!

Maybe.

Eek.



This is a response to the @ecoTrain question of the week contest in collaboration with TribeVibes & 1UP! Join us by answering this question with a great incentive of 100,000 1UP tokens being shared and airdropped to the winners! You can find more information here

image.png

Also, thanks to @nathanmars who kinda pushed me into doing this, though I didn't manage to keep it at a 'snap' at one minute - is it a d snap plus plus? Lol.



B2235A50C31CD126067343B513524EE62.gif

Sort:  

Dear, dear, dear... this was so absoulutely beautiful.. i feel like it was a treatise, a dissemination of your Soul message!! the wisdom of lifetimes of feeling that pain of non acceptance, which can really lodge in there when you're growing up (i know, too, because i was left out a lot in high school by the group of friends i was a part of-- why i chose them as my friends i'm not sure!), and then risking vulnerability and compassion again and again. this is a message for the world! thank you for sharing it and risking yourself with us. i love you even more mangos after watching this!!! and i think you covered it all. i'm sure glad i didn't write my judgment post before watching this because there really is nothing left to say after your words. much love and i'm so glad you're here!!! xoxoxo

Great post, @riverflows - and thanks for putting it on dTube, as it is terrific to finally get a taste of your lovely self and voice. ;-)

You did great, and when all is said and done, you spoke quite naturally, which for your first try out of the box is outstanding!

Yeah, video can be scary, though happily that's a fear I got over a while ago, when I started doing a few videos for my business. I don't tend to edit much, but I have done several takes at times, as necessity dictates.

The hurdle I'll eventually have to cross is doing live video, which I will do at some point, though for now I'll be sticking with prerecorded.

I'm doing most videos with my phone, though occasionally I'll do some with a digital camera on a tripod, though I'm using that less and less as time goes forward. The phone is just easier, especially as I nearly always have it with me, and so it gets bonus points for convenience. ;-)

As for the meat of your post, we are almost completely in agreement, which I'm guessing doesn't surprise you. I'll be addressing it in my own response to this question, which I'll post later tonight, connectivity permitting. ;-)

THANKS!!! So much. I just tried to pretend that I wasn't posting it - @eco-alex gave me that tip lol. It was kinda fun in the end!!! And now it's out, it's out! The ground didn't swallow me up after all!

I think we might do another video on the weekend! Maybe not so personal though, it was kinda full on really.

Looking forward to your response... I think many of us are in agreement, which makes me wonder - why do we fear being judged so much when most of us aren't that judgemental really anyway?

You did great. I'm happy to have gotten to know you a bit here.
You're among my favorite Steemians. ;-)

Oh are you kidding???? Muuuuahhh xxx Humbled and blushing!!!

Posted using Partiko Android

I have trouble being compassionate towards myself. Growing up people around me were judgemental. These days, I worry about telling people that I prefer to stay home rather than go to any holiday dos. I want to warn them in advance. This year I want to choose to say "no" instead of my body deciding for me. Adrenal fatigue/burnout is worst at this time of year and it can make me very sick. The thing I need to remember is that I am already very sick. I need to respect my body and myself. But then does that make me selfish? Will others be disappointed? Will they be upset? Will they never want to see me or talk to me again because I can't make an effort to see them at this occasion? But I'm so tired, and I just want to NOT be bedridden.

So based on my needs and my desire to respect myself and my body, I judge myself with all the possible judgements and things others might think, feel or conclude, which may or may not be true.

Is it adrenal fatigue that makes you bedridden? I've suffered adrenal fatigue too, and know how you feel. Given your worry and concern and self judgement, which is similiar to how I feel when I'm feeling really stressed (which increases cortisol, which can lead to adrenal fatigue) I wonder if the two things are related? I presume so, because when we're super anxious, we get stressed and it releases more cortisol, leading to adrenal fatigue. Which leads to more irrational thinking and being overly critical. NOt sure I'm making sense - it's all a related loop, isn't it? And the thing is, you don't KNOW what your friends are thinking, and if you explain howyou are really feeling, they'd probably totaly empathise and understand! That's what I've taken to doing lately: 'I know this might not be how you're thinking, but this is how I'm feeling' - it seems to really help!xx

It's the fight-flight-freeze response that is out of whack due to CPTSD, which is a big contributing factor. My immune system is weakened due to that. If I overdo it and don't respect my body and its limits, then I will get a fever and sick and will be bedridden. Right now, I'm low in energy, but I'm not bedridden. I don't want to be bedridden. I usually push my body past its low limits in order to please others.

Ugh. Sympathies, and wishes for good mental health to help overcome the physical reaction to trauma xxx Much love xxx

Thanks :) Emotionally I'm doing so much better. Physically, not so much. Working on it ;)

im going to let others comment on the content because i want to comment on the fact you were SO brave and did this wonderful video! GO YOU!!! you are so brave, and even braver than me because you did it for real and didnt hide behind a cartoon ;)_

Love it, and now i feel i know you that much better.. and now you have done one im sure it will be that much easier to do another..

THis is how to heal, we godda just do it <3 CONGRATULATIONS @riverflows, such a milestone!!!

Thanks!!!! To be honest, I've forgotten the content - I'm just glad that I overcame a little milestone. Whether I choose to do another one seems irrelevant now - I'm not even sure I want to - but thanks for giving me the opportunity and coaching me to take this leap as part of my personal journey xxx

River this is super fantastic and I am so happy that you chose to do a video. yay! I love your perspective of judgment and whoa the sunglasses. I really love the earrings and the pretty tree in the background too. much love, eagle spirit

Oh, haha, the sunglasses helped to be honest - they are just cheap ones but at least I was hiding behind SOMETHING! Thanks for your vote of confidence.... xxx

goodness, you are a natural with video. It felt like you were talking just to me! I adore you. I also appreciate your perspective on this weeks question. I can relate to being judged and treated poorly at a young age and the impact it had still has on me today.

I'm not sure that I am a natural lol I felt so awkward and nervous and didn't feel I was expressing myself properly but I thought I would just be myself as much as possible instead of faking it. I am so glad you said that as it did make me feel kinda good.

Posted using Partiko Android

Congratulations @riverflows! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You got more than 3750 replies. Your next target is to reach 4000 replies.

Click here to view your Board of Honor
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:

SteemFest³ - SteemitBoard Contest Teaser
The new Steemfest³ Award is ready!

Support SteemitBoard's project! Vote for its witness and get one more award!

It is very natural to be guarded about being judged by others. The reality is that people are either naturally judgmental (as a survival mechanism) or raised to be judgmental. It takes a lot of maturity to be able to stand on our own without seeking approval of those around us. So then we can edit ourselves so much, to the point of shutting ourselves down before we even start.

I'm so glad you took that leap of faith and made this video on camera. Faith in us!

Hopefully the next will be easier, and then easier and easier.

Yes, exactly, self editing shuts us down - that's a great way of putting it. And yes, I agree - it's often a survival mechanism, or we're mimicing judgemental people around us. My mum was SOOO not judgemental - very open minded and accepting unless people consistantly behave deplorably (like politicians - then see her go!) so I was raised not to be, which is why I was kinda sidelined by the judgements upon me as a kid, and didn't know how to do it back, which would have protected me.

It is so true that it really comes down to how we judge ourselves. <but yes it is only natural to make some judgements as you said it is a survival instinct, but when it goes beyond that and we fail to see the real person infront of us, then we have a problem.
I loved getting to see and hear you and i understand fully that fear of being judged, but you are so loved on here and so humble. I feel the same so many on here have enriched my life, so many xxx

Thanks so much beautiful! Your words mean a lot!!! Yes, I agree - but gee, it's constant effort to NOT judge, but that's okay, as long as we are always making the effort I think!

👋 Just wanted to say I came by. Good job! ❤️ Thank you for being here with us, @riverflows and adding your energy to my life and to Steemit.

Aw was just thinking about you @brightstar!!! That's a beautiful thing to say xx

Posted using Partiko Android

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.25
TRX 0.11
JST 0.032
BTC 62062.59
ETH 3002.04
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.77